Cornell University ProDairy


  • Biological
    • Accumulation of Sediment
      • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
        Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

        Calcite added to the manure system as bedding conditioner and barn floor traction will precipitate out of digesters and cover fixed film components in a digester. Don’t add lime to a manure processing system without a method for calcium removal.
    • Accumulation of Sediment
      • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
        Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

        A conical bottom to facilitate solid removal may prevent solids from remaining in the digester bottom even after a drainpipe is opened. Sediment will accumulate even with flow promoted from outside to the center with a flat bottom.
    • Bedding
      • AA Dairy
        Digested separated manure solids were used for bedding for a short time. Mastitis incidents rose in the milking herd and the bedding was the first potential cause that was eliminated. The risk of additional mastitis makes the use of the manure solids as bedding a detriment.
    • Fixed Film Media
      • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
        Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

        Corrugated Plastic Drainage Tubing can be used as a fixed film media. Four inch diameter CPDT placed 8 feet on end in a ten foot diameter tank provided 11,965 square feet of surface area on the corrugated pipes, 433 square feet on the walls, and 86 square feet on the floor surface area. Other proprietary media may also work. Increasing the surface area to increase the biological activity is the goal of the fixed film.
    • Foam
      • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
        Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

        Foaming issues occurred as changes to the digester feed rate occurred and when the diet of the cows changed. Foam can be controlled with a foam cutter sprayed on the surface at a concentration of 100ppm. Other adoptions to reduce the impact of foaming were raising the gas inlet and increasing the water trap in the gas line.
    • Foam
      • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
        Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

        Shock loading of a digester with high energy food waste will create substantial amounts of foam. Loading the digester incrementally throughout the day reduces the potential for foam.
    • Manure Pumping
      • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
        Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

        Pumping tie stall manure with long hay is still problematic. Farms that need to pump manure for further processing may need to chop bedding and not use the manure as a disposal for refused hay. One point two gallons of water added near the impellor increases the pumping rate of undiluted manure from a tie stall barn.
    • Mixed Digestion
      • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
        Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

        The mixed digester performs well and offers flexibility in operation accepting various consistencies of manure and food waste mixtures. By mixing the influent into the total volume of the digester, the biomass that has been built up in the digester can attack all the new feed. Even though some of the influent goes out of the digester the first day, the total volatile solids reduction is significant and the volatile acids (indicators for odor production) are low.
    • Particle Size
      • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
        Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

        A grinder pump will convert any remaining longer particles of manure into pieces less than 1/4th of an inch. Smaller particles will cause less plugging of heat pipes and provide better digestion.
    • Temperature Control
      • Noblehurst Farms
        Demonstration of a community manure digester project

        Maintaining temperature control during the winter is important. Frozen manure and manure that was too wet was bypassed from the digester. When the digester feed was reduced the gas production slowed and less heat was available to heat the influent and maintain the temperature. Either added external energy would be needed to maintain the digester temperature or the digester would need several months and warmer weather to recover.
    • Temperature Control
      • Noblehurst Farms
        Demonstration of a community manure digester project

        The thermometers were installed reading 3 degrees higher than reality. Checking and calibrating the instrumentation should be an important step in start up procedures.
    • Volatile Acid Levels
      • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
        Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

        Odor control can be achieved by a digester system. The odors are negligible when the volatile acid levels leaving the digester are below 500 ppm. As the digester experiences difficulties with temperature or retention time the volatile acids leaving the digester may be higher and odors may occur.

  • Manure and Effluent Handling
    • Centralized System
      • Noblehurst Farms
        Demonstration of a community manure digester project

        Similar to the town of Perry, the disadvantage of the expense of manure transportation to the community site and transportation of the effluent back to each farm was a huge cost for the community system to overcome.
    • Centralized System
      • Town of Perry
        Feasibility of anaerobic digestion for multiple farms

        The disadvantage of the expense of manure transportation to the centralized site and transportation of the effluent back to each farm was a huge cost for the centralized system to overcome. The energy produced at the centralized site could only be used at the central site to replace electricity at the retail price. Sending the electricity back to the farms would mean paying a wheeling fee to the utility according to NYS law.
    • Cover
      • Twin Birch
        The digester was designed with a hard top to collect the gas at 12 inches of water column pressure to push gas into the compressor. The greater the pressure the more difficulties there are in sealing a digester. Digesters operating at high pressures should be pressure tested as part of the startup procedure. Use proven technologies to seal digesters. Separate any equipment as much as possible from gas sources.
    • Covers
      • Freund
        Translucent ridged greenhouse material was used to cover the digester after the original fabric cover failed. The biogas is withdrawn from the digester under a slight vacuum to prevent leakage of biogas outside the digester. This allows observations of foam levels in the digester.
    • Covers
      • Noblehurst Farms
        Demonstration of a community manure digester project

        Concrete hard tops operating under pressure are very difficult to seal. Leaks of biogas cause loss of gas production and odors on the farm. Pressure testing before filling with manure is time consuming and expensive but apparently needed to ensure that the sealant has been properly applied.
    • Design
      • Freund
        The digester was designed with a center-dividing wall to move the manure down one side and up the other. During construction an opening was created in the dividing wall that allowed short-circuiting of the manure and little treatment and biogas production.
    • Foam
      • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
        Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

        Foaming issues occurred as changes to the digester feed rate occurred and when the diet of the cows changed. Foam can be controlled with a foam cutter sprayed on the surface at a concentration of 100ppm. Other adoptions to reduce the impact of foaming were raising the gas inlet and increasing the water trap in the gas line.
    • Foam
      • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
        Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

        Foaming can occur when changes occur such as: the diet of the cows the temperature of the digester, and additions of other organic loading. Spraying water over the foam can control foaming. A water source and spray device near the effluent tank is useful.
    • Foam
      • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
        Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

        As foaming occurs, it often flows into the pipe chase where the gas collection pipes leave the digester. They have water basins set to provide the pressure needed to keep the cover inflated. Foam flowing out creates a mess. Providing a drain for the pipe chases and a solid bottom and water supply makes clean up easier. Removing the top of the pipe chase allows easy access and good ventilation for those working in the area.
    • Food Waste
      • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
        Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

        Although the food waste brings in additional solids to the digestion system fewer solids are in the effluent than when just manure is digested. The extra energy of the food waste apparently makes it possible for additional solids destruction. Solids were broken down in the effluent storage as well. The existing manure storage was about one half full of manure solids when digested effluent was introduced. After two years of operation, the solids in the storage are almost all gone without excessive agitation.
    • Frozen Manure and Temperature Control
      • Freund
        Utilizing the biogas to run a boiler to heat a grid of pipes allowed the farm to introduce frozen chunks of manure into a preheat chamber. As the manure is thawed the pipe grid keeps the frozen chunks from moving into the digester until they are melted.
    • Mixed Digestion
      • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
        Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

        The mixed digester performs well and offers flexibility in operation accepting various consistencies of manure and food waste mixtures. By mixing the influent into the total volume of the digester, the biomass that has been built up in the digester can attack all the new feed. Even though some of the influent goes out of the digester the first day, the total volatile solids reduction is significant and the volatile acids (indicators for odor production) are low.
    • Moisture Content
      • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
        Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

        The plug-flow digester relies on the proper moisture content of the influent. Dairy manure as produced will not separate into floatable and settable solids very easily. When extra moisture is added, the floatable and settable solids sort out inside the digester, leaving a floating crust and a deposit. As these two portions of the digester get larger they will decrease the usable volume and the hydraulic retention time. Lower retention times will decrease biogas production and fail to reduce the odors in the effluent.
    • Sand Laden Dairy Manure
      • Spring Valley
        Sand laden dairy manure (SLDM) can be removed with a retrofitted gutter cleaner running at the heated inlet. As sand is dropped out the chain driven gutter cleaner is turned on coming out of the digester though air lock to load a manure spreader with SLDM. A ramp still exists to be able to drive down into the storage to remove any solid manure or sand that is not removed by the gutter cleaner.
    • Service Support
      • AA Dairy
        Service support for the engine, generator, electrical inter-tie, and other parts are still not provided by one entity leaving the farm to find the best and quickest solution to a variety of problems. At times the small problem that goes unfixed for a time can lead to more difficult problems. There is an opportunity for a maintenance specialist to assist farms in running the systems that are part of an anaerobic digestion manure treatment process.
    • Storage
      • Spring Valley
        Inoculation of the manure in a long-term storage can reduce the odors of the manure. Originally discovered serendipitously, the system treating only a small portion of the manure in a controlled temperature digester can reduce the odor of all the manure given time. This means that for a low capital cost odor control can be achieved.
    • System Uniformity
      • Noblehurst Farms
        Demonstration of a community manure digester project

        Complete engine skids and gas handling skids that have been factory installed to meet the specifications of the specific installation provide design and construction convenience. The systems are put together with compatible equipment and controls so on farm hassles are reduced.
    • Temperature Control
      • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
        Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

        Temperature control of the digester is critical. Air locks in the heat pipes can prevent the proper circulation of the heated water inside the digester to heat the incoming manure to 100° F and to keep it at that temperature throughout the 20 day retention time. Temperature gauges, if they work properly, show the lack of heat, however, if the temperature gauges are not calibrated, then the lack of heat in the digester may go undetected. Groundwater impingement on the bottom of the digester can take a significant amount of heat away from the digester making it hard to heat. When flows to the digester are curtailed, the amount of heat to the digester needs to be adjusted since heat will not be needed for incoming manure. Without adjustment higher temperatures than desired may result.
    • Temperature Control
      • Noblehurst Farms
        Demonstration of a community manure digester project

        Maintaining temperature control during the winter is important. Frozen manure and manure that was too wet was bypassed from the digester. When the digester feed was reduced the gas production slowed and less heat was available to heat the influent and maintain the temperature. Either added external energy would be needed to maintain the digester temperature or the digester would need several months and warmer weather to recover.
    • Twin Digestion construction
      • Noblehurst Farms
        Demonstration of a community manure digester project

        The twin digester construction to avoid an excessively long digester and reasonable spans for the concrete top is a viable design. This should make it possible to shut down and start up each side independently and therefore easier. It is hard to divide the influent equally to the two digesters; a flow meter along with the control device may be needed.
    • Weir Wall
      • AA Dairy
        The weir wall consisting of timbers set across the concrete opening at the outlet of the digester failed. Until repairs were made the outlet reception pit needed to be kept full to prevent the loss of gas.

    • Separation
      • Accumulation of Sediment
        • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
          Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

          A conical bottom to facilitate solid removal may prevent solids from remaining in the digester bottom even after a drainpipe is opened. Sediment will accumulate even with flow promoted from outside to the center with a flat bottom.
      • Bedding
        • AA Dairy
          Digested separated manure solids were used for bedding for a short time. Mastitis incidents rose in the milking herd and the bedding was the first potential cause that was eliminated. The risk of additional mastitis makes the use of the manure solids as bedding a detriment.
      • Moisture Content
        • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

          The plug-flow digester relies on the proper moisture content of the influent. Dairy manure as produced will not separate into floatable and settable solids very easily. When extra moisture is added, the floatable and settable solids sort out inside the digester, leaving a floating crust and a deposit. As these two portions of the digester get larger they will decrease the usable volume and the hydraulic retention time. Lower retention times will decrease biogas production and fail to reduce the odors in the effluent.
      • Separation
        • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
          Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

          An external shell and tube heat exchanger made with ¾ inch pipe can work in digesters on separated liquid. An automatic back flush device operating for 26 seconds every 2 hours will keep plugging from occurring. The external heat exchanger allows maintenance to occur without opening up the digester.
      • Separation before Digestion
        • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
          Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

          Separation ahead of digestion removes 30% of the Biodegradable Volatile Solids. The solids removed are about 1 cubic foot per cow per day, and consist of about 27% solids and are 20% of the mass. The liquids, about 17 gallons and 80% of the mass, consist of about 6% solids. The liquids are able to be pumped after the separator.
      • Solids vs. Liquids
        • Kreher’s Poultry Farms
          Poultry waste drying and composting demonstration

          Handling chicken manure as a solid instead of as a liquid has significant advantages in odor control and reduced volume of material. Previously liquid manure was scraped and flushed to a holding pond and then land applied. Adopting the composting system eliminated odors, flies and runoff concerns.

    • Gas Production
      • Cleaning Fuel Cells
        • Cornell University
          Feasibility study of fuel cells using biogas from anaerobic digestion

          Biogas containing H2S and CO2 will need to be cleaned before it can be used by the fuel cell. There are a variety of ways that this can be done. CO2 removal may be the limiting factor on the relatively small sized farm operations.
      • Cost of Fuel Cells
        • Cornell University
          Feasibility study of fuel cells using biogas from anaerobic digestion

          The capital costs of fuel cells are still too high to justify their use on farms at this time. Potential lower cost manufacturing methods and efficiencies created by mass production may bring the price down.
      • Cover
        • Twin Birch
          The digester was designed with a hard top to collect the gas at 12 inches of water column pressure to push gas into the compressor. The greater the pressure the more difficulties there are in sealing a digester. Digesters operating at high pressures should be pressure tested as part of the startup procedure. Use proven technologies to seal digesters. Separate any equipment as much as possible from gas sources.
      • Flare Problems
        • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

          The 3” pipe leading to the flare was designed to take excess gas to the flare. When none of the gas is being used the pipe is too small and a blow out in the pipe chase occurs. Keeping the flare lit during windy conditions and when both high and low biogas flows are present is difficult. Two automatic spark producers are needed to provide a spark where a flammable mixture of biogas and oxygen is present.
      • Food Waste
        • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

          Gas handling pipes, flares and enterprises for energy use need to be used for the additional production that a food waste system will require. Pre-planning and analysis of potential food waste should be done to estimate the gas production and the size of the utilization equipment.
      • Food Waste
        • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

          The food waste is high in energy having three times the gas production per unit of mass than manure, yet the nutrient content is comparable to manure so imported nutrients are kept low. Not all farms can take advantage of this. Only farms that have a land base that can accept the extra nutrients should consider this option.
      • Fuel Cell Efficiency
        • Cornell University
          Feasibility study of fuel cells using biogas from anaerobic digestion

          Improved efficiencies in energy conversion would be profitable. Present efficiencies in the 20 to 30 percent range of converting potential energy to electricity are poor. Raising these efficiencies to 40-60 percent by using fuel cells holds a promise of higher returns.
      • Gas Conditioning
        • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

          Gas conditioning for the compressors and micro-turbines is critical. Hydrogen Sulfide and water vapor in the gas present the potential for corrosion. Methods to remove a significant portion of these contaminants are crucial. The compressor may have sensitive components that will corrode. The output from the compressor must be reduced in moisture content and have no excess oil in it or the micro-turbines may fail.
      • Gas Production
        • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
          Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

          A 5-day retention time in a fixed film digester will provide odor control as well as 30 cubic foot of biogas per cow per day. The gas production is sufficient to maintain operating temperatures in the digester with a biogas boiler even during the winter.
      • Temperature Control
        • Noblehurst Farms
          Demonstration of a community manure digester project

          Maintaining temperature control during the winter is important. Frozen manure and manure that was too wet was bypassed from the digester. When the digester feed was reduced the gas production slowed and less heat was available to heat the influent and maintain the temperature. Either added external energy would be needed to maintain the digester temperature or the digester would need several months and warmer weather to recover.
      • Weir Wall
        • AA Dairy
          The weir wall consisting of timbers set across the concrete opening at the outlet of the digester failed. Until repairs were made the outlet reception pit needed to be kept full to prevent the loss of gas.

    • Engine
      • Engine
        • AA Dairy
          The engine selected was based more on the price than the most efficient size. A used engine became available and was put into service. An oversized engine will be inefficient in converting fuel to power at lower operating speeds. Building the digester for 1,000 cows while only operating it at half capacity does cause some inefficiency.
      • Exhaust Pipe
        • Noblehurst Farms
          Demonstration of a community manure digester project

          Burying the exhaust pipe and out letting it some distance from the engine room keeps corrosion away from building and keeps noise down. Internal combustion engines are loud. Sound control may be needed on some sites.
      • Heat
        • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

          The waste heat given off by the engine generator is significant. Utilizing the coolant to heat the influent and maintain the digester temperature and using it for heat exchangers for hot water in the calf barn and milking parlor still requires a radiator to dissipate extra heat. Even in the winter the un-insulated engine building is very warm. This makes a very good heated shop and should be used for that function.
      • Noise
        • AA Dairy
          The noise from the motor in an un-insulated pole barn can be loud. Providing a sound insulated engine room reduces the sound at the farm as well as the sound at a distance. People that had been keeping their window shut from the odors were now complaining about the sound.

    • Electric
      • Fuel Cell Efficiency
        • Cornell University
          Feasibility study of fuel cells using biogas from anaerobic digestion

          Improved efficiencies in energy conversion would be profitable. Present efficiencies in the 20 to 30 percent range of converting potential energy to electricity are poor. Raising these efficiencies to 40-60 percent by using fuel cells holds a promise of higher returns.
      • Hot Water
        • AA Dairy
          The projected savings from hot water use did not materialize since changing from the existing radiant heat to hot water heat in the parlor would have cost too much. Since the electricity produced by the on farm generation covers the electric needs of the farm there was not a big incentive in making an expensive change.

    • Heat
      • Frozen Manure and Temperature Control
        • Freund
          Utilizing the biogas to run a boiler to heat a grid of pipes allowed the farm to introduce frozen chunks of manure into a preheat chamber. As the manure is thawed the pipe grid keeps the frozen chunks from moving into the digester until they are melted.
      • Heat
        • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

          The waste heat given off by the engine generator is significant. Utilizing the coolant to heat the influent and maintain the digester temperature and using it for heat exchangers for hot water in the calf barn and milking parlor still requires a radiator to dissipate extra heat. Even in the winter the un-insulated engine building is very warm. This makes a very good heated shop and should be used for that function.
      • Heating Barn
        • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

          Heat pipes in the barn floor may not keep manure from freezing during weather colder than 5 degrees F. Although heat can be supplied continuously from the heat recovered off the electrical generation system, during sharp cold snaps the in floor heat cannot prevent freezing.
      • Heating system
        • Twin Birch
          The heating system had several flaws. The heat balance of the digester system is vital. Designs need to address the heat recovery from the biogas, methods to heat the incoming manure, and correct estimates of the maintenance heat needed to maintain a constant temperature in all weather conditions.
      • Hot Water
        • AA Dairy
          The projected savings from hot water use did not materialize since changing from the existing radiant heat to hot water heat in the parlor would have cost too much. Since the electricity produced by the on farm generation covers the electric needs of the farm there was not a big incentive in making an expensive change.
      • Particle Size
        • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
          Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

          A grinder pump will convert any remaining longer particles of manure into pieces less than 1/4th of an inch. Smaller particles will cause less plugging of heat pipes and provide better digestion.
      • Site Drainage
        • Twin Birch
          Drains to control the water table around the digester to prevent buoyancy of the empty digester and to control heat loss were not designed. All in ground structures should have drainage systems in the backfill to reduce heat loss and prevent floatation.
      • Temperature Control
        • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

          Temperature control of the digester is critical. Air locks in the heat pipes can prevent the proper circulation of the heated water inside the digester to heat the incoming manure to 100° F and to keep it at that temperature throughout the 20 day retention time. Temperature gauges, if they work properly, show the lack of heat, however, if the temperature gauges are not calibrated, then the lack of heat in the digester may go undetected. Groundwater impingement on the bottom of the digester can take a significant amount of heat away from the digester making it hard to heat. When flows to the digester are curtailed, the amount of heat to the digester needs to be adjusted since heat will not be needed for incoming manure. Without adjustment higher temperatures than desired may result.
      • Temperature Control
        • Noblehurst Farms
          Demonstration of a community manure digester project

          The thermometers were installed reading 3 degrees higher than reality. Checking and calibrating the instrumentation should be an important step in start up procedures.
      • Temperature Control
        • Noblehurst Farms
          Demonstration of a community manure digester project

          Maintaining temperature control during the winter is important. Frozen manure and manure that was too wet was bypassed from the digester. When the digester feed was reduced the gas production slowed and less heat was available to heat the influent and maintain the temperature. Either added external energy would be needed to maintain the digester temperature or the digester would need several months and warmer weather to recover.

    • Management of Anaerobic Digestion
      • Centralized System
        • Noblehurst Farms
          Demonstration of a community manure digester project

          Similar to the town of Perry, the disadvantage of the expense of manure transportation to the community site and transportation of the effluent back to each farm was a huge cost for the community system to overcome.
      • Centralized System
        • Town of Perry
          Feasibility of anaerobic digestion for multiple farms

          Benefits of a centralized system include economies of scale for the design, construction, and operation. Although more complex, a centralized system (since it would have to provide for influent from several farms instead of one) would still be easier to design than four separate systems on the individual farms. Constructing one combined system would be cheaper than constructing four separate systems on four separate sites. Operating and maintaining one system would be cheaper and could use more specialized management than each farm operating and maintaining a digester.
      • Centralized System
        • Town of Perry
          Feasibility of anaerobic digestion for multiple farms

          The recommended choice was to have the individual sites cooperate on one designer and setting up a cooperative maintenance agreement. Some of the cost saving can be obtained without having to transport the manure and having each farm replace electricity produced for retail electricity used on each farm.
      • Choosing a Company
        • Twin Birch
          Choosing an engineering company to design and build the digester can be confusing. It is important to review the experiences and references of the
      • Continuous System Improvement
        • Spring Valley
          Incremental improvements of the system to match the capital expenditures with benefits provided can be part of the system. First, by building the small digester to achieve odor reduction, then adding a cover to collect the gas emissions from the manure storage to flare. Adding an engine to utilize the gas for on-farm power production and finally adding heat recovery to provide more than ambient temperatures to the main manure storage to facilitate digestion. Each of these components can be added incrementally.
      • Cost Estimate
        • Twin Birch
          The cost estimate for this project was under $500,000. The actual cost to date has been over $1,000,000. Obtain realistic cost estimates and include plans for exigencies.
      • Cover Construction
        • Spring Valley
          Retrofitting a fabric cover on existing concrete manure storage allowed the gas produced in the storage to be collected. Reinforced fiber strips supported by a center pole support the cover when the gas pressure is too low
      • Covers
        • Noblehurst Farms
          Demonstration of a community manure digester project

          Concrete hard tops operating under pressure are very difficult to seal. Leaks of biogas cause loss of gas production and odors on the farm. Pressure testing before filling with manure is time consuming and expensive but apparently needed to ensure that the sealant has been properly applied.
      • Foam
        • Watershed Agricultural Council, Inc.
          Demonstrations of fixed film anaerobic digester

          Foaming issues occurred as changes to the digester feed rate occurred and when the diet of the cows changed. Foam can be controlled with a foam cutter sprayed on the surface at a concentration of 100ppm. Other adoptions to reduce the impact of foaming were raising the gas inlet and increasing the water trap in the gas line.
      • Foam
        • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

          Shock loading of a digester with high energy food waste will create substantial amounts of foam. Loading the digester incrementally throughout the day reduces the potential for foam.
      • Food Waste
        • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

          Gas handling pipes, flares and enterprises for energy use need to be used for the additional production that a food waste system will require. Pre-planning and analysis of potential food waste should be done to estimate the gas production and the size of the utilization equipment.
      • Noise
        • AA Dairy
          The noise from the motor in an un-insulated pole barn can be loud. Providing a sound insulated engine room reduces the sound at the farm as well as the sound at a distance. People that had been keeping their window shut from the odors were now complaining about the sound.
      • Service Support
        • AA Dairy
          Service support for the engine, generator, electrical inter-tie, and other parts are still not provided by one entity leaving the farm to find the best and quickest solution to a variety of problems. At times the small problem that goes unfixed for a time can lead to more difficult problems. There is an opportunity for a maintenance specialist to assist farms in running the systems that are part of an anaerobic digestion manure treatment process.
      • System Design
        • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

          The design of the anaerobic digestion system including manure handling, gas collection, gas utilization, and digester heating should not just be designed by each individual component but designed as a system. This site experienced a beam failure due to lateral loads that were not anticipated by the concrete designer. If the concrete design had been better integrated with the rest of the project they may have realized that lateral loads could develop.
      • Temperature Control
        • Noblehurst Farms
          Demonstration of a community manure digester project

          The thermometers were installed reading 3 degrees higher than reality. Checking and calibrating the instrumentation should be an important step in start up procedures.

    • Site Consideration
      • Centralized System
        • Noblehurst Farms
          Demonstration of a community manure digester project

          Similar to the town of Perry, the disadvantage of the expense of manure transportation to the community site and transportation of the effluent back to each farm was a huge cost for the community system to overcome.
      • Centralized System
        • Town of Perry
          Feasibility of anaerobic digestion for multiple farms

          Benefits of a centralized system include economies of scale for the design, construction, and operation. Although more complex, a centralized system (since it would have to provide for influent from several farms instead of one) would still be easier to design than four separate systems on the individual farms. Constructing one combined system would be cheaper than constructing four separate systems on four separate sites. Operating and maintaining one system would be cheaper and could use more specialized management than each farm operating and maintaining a digester.
      • Noise
        • AA Dairy
          The noise from the motor in an un-insulated pole barn can be loud. Providing a sound insulated engine room reduces the sound at the farm as well as the sound at a distance. People that had been keeping their window shut from the odors were now complaining about the sound.
      • Odor Controls
        • AA Dairy
          Treated separated digested liquid manure from the cow barn when added to the Heifer barn’s manure storage pond reduces the odor in that storage. This means that to control the odors on a farm system not all the manure has to be brought to the digester itself.
      • Weather
        • F.A.R.M.E. Institute, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration with biogas fueled micro-turbines

          Heavy snow load can collapse the flexible cover on the digester if it falls faster than it can melt. Shoveling the snow off will allow the cover to inflate.

    • Environmental Issues of Anaerobic Digestion
      • Environment
        • Twin Birch
          Power generation problems at this site are due to the corrosive environment. Carefully analyze your facility design to limit potential adverse impacts on equipment.
      • Food Waste
        • Matlink Dairy Farm, Inc.
          Anaerobic digester demonstration illustrating environmental benefits

          Accepting food waste is highly profitable. The tipping fees make the manure treatment system a profit center for the farm. This is a win-win-win situation. The farm gets a payment to accept the food waste and the extra energy as the volatile solids are converted to methane, the food company has an environmentally responsible and relatively cheap way to get rid of their waste product and the nutrients from the food waste are recycled back to the land while green energy is produced.
      • Odor Controls
        • AA Dairy
          Treated separated digested liquid manure from the cow barn when added to the Heifer barn’s manure storage pond reduces the odor in that storage. This means that to control the odors on a farm system not all the manure has to be brought to the digester itself.